The CookieFirst alternative that doesn't charge per domain
Free scan: what loads on your site before consent?
See which cookies and trackers start before anyone clicks — with CookieFirst installed or without. No sign-up.
CookieFirst is an Amsterdam-based consent platform from Digital Data Solutions BV, an iubenda company. It's Google-certified, offers IAB TCF on its Plus plan and supports 44 languages. Every domain and subdomain needs its own subscription, though, so costs add up across sites. PrivacyPill's Pro plan covers all of them for one flat price.
Facts checked against CookieFirst's own pages · Sources
At a glance
- Pricing
- PrivacyPillFree for 1 domain, Pro €9/mo or €79/yr, Lifetime €49 onceCookieFirstFree; Basic €9/mo or €99/yr; Plus €19/mo or €209/yr — per domain, excl. VAT; Enterprise on request
- What sets your price
- PrivacyPillNothing — flat per planCookieFirstEach domain or subdomain needs its own subscription; volume discounts on request
- Lifetime license
- PrivacyPillYes — €49, 1 domain, unlimited pageviewsCookieFirstNone listed
- Google-certified CMP
- PrivacyPillNoCookieFirstYes (CMP ID 382)
PrivacyPill vs. CookieFirst
Facts checked
| Feature | PrivacyPill | CookieFirst |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Free for 1 domain, Pro €9/mo or €79/yr, Lifetime €49 once | Free; Basic €9/mo or €99/yr; Plus €19/mo or €209/yr — per domain, excl. VAT; Enterprise on request |
| What sets your price | Nothing — flat per plan | Each domain or subdomain needs its own subscription; volume discounts on request |
| Traffic | Free 5,000 pageviews/mo; Pro and Lifetime unlimited | Soft limit per domain (the site shows both 250,000 and 300,000 pageviews a month) |
| Free plan | Full banner with Consent Mode v2, all six languages and the consent log | One third-party script, one language, banner only, one scan at signup |
| Lifetime license | Yes — €49, 1 domain, unlimited pageviews | None listed |
| Google Consent Mode v2 | Built in on every plan (advanced mode: denied defaults, update on choice) | Basic and advanced setups documented |
| Google-certified CMP | No | Yes (CMP ID 382) |
| IAB TCF (ad publishers) | No | Plus only (the site names both TCF 2.2 and 2.4) |
| Banner languages | 6 European languages on every plan | 44 languages on paid plans; one on Free |
| Cookie scanning | On-demand scanner; automatic monthly rescans on Pro | Once at signup on Free; every 30 days on paid plans |
| Proof of consent | Consent log with CSV export on every plan (30 days on Free, 12 months paid) | CSV export on Basic; audit trails on Plus |
| Vendor branding | Small badge on Free only | White-label banner on Basic and Plus; white-label panel on Plus |
CookieFirst details checked on 9 November 2026 against cookiefirst.com and the pages listed under Sources. Plans and prices change — always confirm on cookiefirst.com before you decide. CookieFirst is a trademark of its owner; we're not affiliated. See sources
Also comparing other tools to CookieFirst?
- PrivacyPill vs. CookieHubNo session tiers, and a free plan with more headroom.CookieHub alternative
- PrivacyPill vs. iubendaAll six languages and geo-targeting without the top tier.iubenda alternative
- PrivacyPill vs. AxeptioA free plan for 5,000 pageviews, not 200 visitors.Axeptio alternative
- PrivacyPill vs. CookieYesUnlimited pageviews on Pro, no overage fees.CookieYes alternative
Is PrivacyPill right for you?
An honest answer, including where CookieFirst is the better tool.
PrivacyPill fits if
- You run several domains or subdomains — shop, blog, docs — and want one plan for all of them.
- Your free-plan site loads more than one third-party script.
- You want automatic rescans and geo-targeting at €9 a month in total, not per domain.
- You'd rather pay once: €49 for one domain.
Choose CookieFirst if
- You need IAB TCF and a Google-certified CMP for advertising (Plus).
- You need more than six languages, or a native Shopify app.
- You want an in-app consent audit trail for each visitor.
Limits to know first
- No IAB TCF and not a Google-certified CMP, so it doesn't fit AdSense, Ad Manager or AdMob ads shown to visitors in the EEA, UK or Switzerland.
- Six banner languages: English, German, French, Dutch, Spanish and Italian.
- No automatic script blocking: Google tags follow Consent Mode, other scripts and embeds need a data-pp-category attribute.
- The free plan covers one domain up to 5,000 pageviews a month, shows a small PrivacyPill badge and keeps consent records for 30 days (12 months on paid plans).
- A young product from a small studio (Kalmwerk); support is by email.
- Pro and Lifetime aren't on sale yet: the free plan works today, and you can join the waitlist for the paid plans.
Check your current setup first — free, no sign-up
Our pre-consent check loads your page like a first-time visitor and lists the cookies and trackers that start before anyone clicks. Run it with CookieFirst installed to see whether its blocking works, and again after a switch.
Using Google Ads or GA4? Check your Consent Mode v2 setup too
Prefer a free banner?
No sign-up and no licence key. The plugin and the open-source banner run entirely on your own site.
Running WordPress? Install the free plugin
A settings page in your dashboard, Accept and Reject with equal weight, Consent Mode v2 and script blocking. No outside requests by default.
v1.2.3 · ZIP 281 kB · GPLv2+
Rather self-host? Use the open-source banner
One 8.9 kB file under the MIT licence with Accept, Reject, categories and Consent Mode v2. It never calls our servers.
v1.2.1 · MIT · GitHub
Per-domain pricing adds up
CookieFirst's support centre is clear: each domain or subdomain needs a separate subscription. Three sites on Basic is €27 a month; add a shop subdomain and it's €36. PrivacyPill Pro is €9 a month (or €79 a year) for unlimited domains, and subdomains are covered by their domain.
CookieFirst's free plan is limited to one third-party script and one language, with a single scan at signup. PrivacyPill's free plan has no script limit and includes all six languages, Consent Mode v2 and the consent log — it stops at 5,000 pageviews a month.
Two things CookieFirst's site doesn't agree on
On the day we checked, CookieFirst's homepage gave the paid plans' soft traffic limit as 300,000 pageviews per domain a month in one place and 250,000 in another, and named TCF 2.4 in one table and TCF 2.2 in another. Ask CookieFirst which applies before you buy.
Switching from CookieFirst
CookieFirst blocks scripts with type="text/plain" and data-cookiefirst-category="performance", "advertising" or "functional". Change those to data-pp-category="analytics", "marketing" or "functional" (necessary scripts need no attribute), replace the CookieFirst script with the PrivacyPill embed as the first script in <head>, and run the free pre-consent check.
What CookieFirst users report
Public complaints about CookieFirst are few and mostly dated: the themes below come from Capterra reviews written in 2021–2022, read on 9 November 2026. Its Trustpilot and Shopify ratings are higher. Treat them as historical customer reports.
Slow consent interactions (2022)
Two reviewers described the banner or consent API responding slowly at times.
Admin interface friction (2021–2022)
Several reviewers found the dashboard slow or functions hard to find.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
CookieFirst facts on this page come from these pages, read on . Spotted something out of date? Write to kalmwerk@gmail.com and we'll correct it.
More comparisons
See all- Cookiebot alternativeWhy people switch, six alternatives, a cost calculator and a 15-minute switch.
- Complianz alternativeWordPress or any website, free or a one-time price, Consent Mode v2 on every plan.
- CookieYes alternativeUnlimited pageviews on Pro, no overage fees.
- OneTrust alternativePublic prices and self-serve checkout instead of a quote.
- Usercentrics alternativeNo session tiers or automatic plan upgrades.
- iubenda alternativeAll six languages and geo-targeting without the top tier.
- Termly alternativeGeo-targeting and consent exports without the top plan.
- Borlabs Cookie alternativeAny platform, and €49 once instead of €49 a year.
- Osano alternativeA flat €9 instead of $199 a month for small teams.
- Didomi alternativePublic prices and a free plan instead of a sales call.
- Axeptio alternativeA free plan for 5,000 pageviews, not 200 visitors.
- CookieHub alternativeNo session tiers, and a free plan with more headroom.
Try it on your own site
Design your banner, preview it live, and paste one line. Free for one domain.